Rise in Surveyor Negligence Claims by Property Investors - Reports Lawyer

1st December 2011

A LEADING professional negligence expert at national law firm, Irwin Mitchell, is reporting an increase in the region of 20% in the number of cases in which homeowners have launched proceedings against surveyors for overvaluing their property before they bought it.

Daniel Brumpton, an Associate Solicitor in the Commercial Litigation  Team at Irwin Mitchell's Sheffield office, claims that the number of new enquiries from people who believe they are the victim of negligence by surveyors is on the rise - with the largest proportion of cases coming from buy-to-let investors. Commenting on the increase, Mr.Brumpton said: -The increase in buy-to-let property investment ahead of the credit crunch has been well-documented. Many of these landlords have however since struggled to find tenants due to an over supply in some cities and this in turn has forced many to sell in order to avoid defaulting on their mortgage. -Landlords rely on surveyors to provide both an accurate valuation of the property as well as the likely rental income that will be achieved. It appears, however, that an increasing number are alleging significant discrepancies between the true market value and the figures provided in surveyor reports.  A recent Court of Appeal decision in June 2011 (Scullion v Bank of Scotland Plc) provided some relief for surveyors when it supported a firm of surveyors in their role when providing valuation advice to a buy-to-let investor. In this case the judge argued that the surveyor did not have a duty of care as it would be reasonable, due to the size and sophistication of the investor, for them to expect that the buyer would have paid for their own report. Mr. Brumpton believes therefore that there is still scope for 'modest' buy-to-let investors to make successful claims. He said: -The Court of Appeal's decision in Scullion v Bank of Scotland Plc case earlier this year arguably made it more difficult for large professional property investors to successfully make claims for negligence. In the case of more modest investors however the door certainly hasn't closed and surveyors should be on notice of the risk of such claims. -I've noticed what is roughly a 20% rise in enquires during the last 12 months and there certainly hasn't been a fall since the Court of Appeal's decision. With the current state of the property market, I would expect the number of investors considering bringing such claims over the next year will go up even more.  

You might also be interested in

South Yorkshire’s International Trade Conference Returns Next Month

Fri 14th June 2024

The South Yorkshire International Trade Conference returns bigger and better this year and takes place on July 3.

Applications open for The Sheffield Business Awards 2024

Wed 15th May 2024

Applications are now open for the region’s most prestigious and long-standing business awards, recognising people and companies excelling in their field.

South Yorkshire Businesses Asked to Share Their Views On Local Town and City Centres

Mon 13th May 2024

As part of a new poll being conducted by the three regional South Yorkshire Chambers of Commerce, businesses are being asked to share their views on what the priorities should be for their nearest town or city centre.

UK Goods Trade Struggling For Impact

Fri 10th May 2024

William Bain, Head of Trade Policy at the British Chambers of Commerce, responds to the latest ONS Trade figures published this morning.